Looking At The Reaction to the Election Explains its Result


When we look back at the election results, one of the dominant questions has been Why did Labour’s share of the vote actually decrease in many areas of England? Although the Conservative majority was largely won by the collapse of Labour in Scotland and the Liberal Democrats in the West Country, the Conservatives took many Labour marginals, such as Southampton Itchen, and Labour failed to take key Conservative marginals such as North Warwickshire and Broxtowe. Why did the opposition party take such a route in an election after a long period of economic problems? Why did Labour lose the momentum so catastrophically during the campaign?

The answer for many, of course, is that the British electorate is inherently selfish and ignorant. Cameron had not been formally reappointed Prime Minister before Lord Kinnock and other Labour grandees were on TV bemoaning the electorate for not understanding Labour and for putting self-interest first. The following day, the Comment is Free section of the Guardian website was running articles with such titles as ‘A nightmarish result – but a politics of hope could rise from these ashes’ and ‘Democracy is a religion that has failed the poor’. The internet becomes filled with articles about how anyone who voted Conservative or UKIP is not quite a full member of the human race and demanding that they should all arrange a meeting with the 5 year olds they presumably want to send down coal mines in order to instill a more correct way of thinking. Talking about the election in hyperbolic terms, as if Colonel Gaddafi’s reanimated corpse had taken power, becomes a way to assert one’s Correctness.

Perhaps the best way to explain Labour’s defeat is through the response made by many to it. Those of us who hail from the Labour heartlands, the great cities of the Midlands and the North, the central belt of Scotland or the Welsh valleys, will be quite well acquainted already. The assumption of support from these regions has eventually resulted in a certain degree of contempt for the voters there. I think back to my own hometown in Nottinghamshire, where the area voted Labour every election without fail but nothing changed. There was no attempt to improve the region, even with Labour governments. Miliband’s campaign was largely built on the infamous ‘35% strategy’, that Labour could edge into office through tribal voting in the heartlands. No attempt to connect to the centre ground of the electorate, the Labour campaign portrayed a Britain of extremes. Britain was inhabited by The Bosses who flew around in private jets and the rest of us, who lived in a neo-Dickensian nightmare of food banks and zero hour contracts. Although social inequality is a growing problem that the author is concerned about, this way of thinking completely ignores the fact that for the vast majority of people, neither extreme reflects their lives.

Labour has lost its traditional vote and increasing becomes a party even more London-centric than the Tories, even less able to understand the ‘core voters’ than the Tories understand the needs of those in the rural South. And so why is it a surprise that they lost so badly? The over-reliance on polls showed us one thing, the Shy Tory Factor is alive and well. Frankly, given the responses, particularly on social media, to anyone who outs themselves as a Conservative voter, it’s not hard to see why. UKIP are now second in many safe Labour seats, most dramatically in the Heywood and Middleton by-election last year. Rather than assuming that the electorate is now made up of tracksuited lager drinkers or whatever, we have to point to discontent with Labour but lack of a better alternative in regions where the Conservatives still have an image problem.

People point to the electoral system, which does obviously need reform. However, they forget that even under PR, the dominant force would be a Tory/UKIP coalition. Clearly the system is not what keeps Labour out. People point to the fact that the Tories got less than an absolute majority of votes making them not the ‘legitimate’ party, although the last time any party did this was in 1931. Even in the great landslides of 1945, 1959, 1983 and 1997, no party achieved this feat.

The other issue is how the ‘Murdoch Press’ decided the election. The implication, of course, is that Sun readers lack the critical faculties to decide who to vote for. Nobody has complained about the way in which the Mirror and the Guardian set an agenda just as strongly as the Sun and the Times do. Newspapers write to their audience far more than they try and make them think in a particular way. More or less every national daily has a particular demographic they write for. We can all imagine a stereotypical Sun, Guardian or Telegraph reader, and it seems strange to blame the right-leaning press for writing towards a right-leaning audience. Maybe the ‘fear-mongering’ over immigration and the prospect of a Labour-SNP coalition reflected the concerns of many over the scale of mass immigration or that the government may be controlled by a party which does not want to be in our country in the first place?

To sum up, the hysteria that has surrounded the election results amongst many on the Left largely betrays why Labour lost. It shows a Labour campaign that focused on a comparatively small section of the electorate, rather than the middle ground that normally decides elections, a party that has lost touch with traditional supporters and a constant assumption of moral superiority, and by extension moral inferiority of the Tories. The image painted of the next 5 years is that of a Charles Dickens novel in the 21st century, because that is how the country was shown to be in the election campaign. It is not the fault of Labour, so it seems, for running a flawed campaign full of woeful misjudgments, but of the electorate for being heartless and not understanding the message.

More articles in General Election 2015
  1. Labour Party and Business: A Difficult Relationship?
  2. Chameleon Conservative Cameron Shows True Colours
  3. An Election Reflection for a Majority Minority
  4. Mhairi Black: Giving Politics a Makeover
  5. Galloway Threatens Legal Action Over Election Result
  6. Voter Turnout: What The Numbers Tell Us About The 2015 General Election
  7. Looking At The Reaction to the Election Explains its Result
  8. The Polls Were Wrong Because People Lied, it’s That Simple!
  9. Russell Brand “Resigns” from Politics following General Election Result
  10. It’s Not The Cold War Anymore, We Don’t Need a Nuclear Deterrent
  11. The Future of Labour: Who Will Be The Next Leader?
  12. The Future of the Liberal Democrats: Who Will Be the Next Leader?
  13. The Future of UKIP: Who Will Be the Next Leader?
  14. A Tale of Three Ends
  15. The Tory Legacy
  16. If the Party Leaders were characters from Friends…who would you vote for?
  17. The Ten (Well, Six) Commitments: Is Stone Legally Binding?
  18. Tuition Fees: A Hollow Attempt to Pander to the Student Vote?
  19. 6,417 Ed Milligrams – What Do You Actually Vote For?
  20. Boris Johnson to become Gangster Rapper
  21. Political Engagement: The Calm After the Storm
  22. Parliamentary Candidate Interview: Green Party’s John Spottiswoode.
  23. Parliamentary Candidate Interviews: TUSC’s Sue Atkins
  24. Parliamentary Candidate Interview, Independent Candidate Chris Daviss
  25. “I don’t think the Liberal Democrats should be in government just for the sake of it” – An Interview With Nick Clegg
  26. Parliamentary Candidate Interview, TUSC’s Nick Chaffey
  27. Parliamentary Candidate Interview: Conservative’s Jeremy Moulton.
  28. Should Young People Be Made To Vote?
  29. The Nationalist Parties
  30. No Votes for Women?
  31. None of the Political Candidates Ticking Your Box? There is Another Option.
  32. The Other Parties
  33. Liberal Democrats Party Profile
  34. The Green Party
  35. Labour Party Profile
  36. In Defence of the Coalition
  37. Why Labour Should Win the Election But Won’t
  38. The Protest Vote: The Weapon of the Disenfranchised.
  39. Why Young People Must Use Their Vote
  40. An Interview With Natalie Bennett
  41. What Will a Multi-Party System Mean for Britain?
  42. Tuition Fees: Must Try Harder Ed
  43. Science and Policy
  44. This Election is Far Bigger Than Party Politics
  45. Parliamentary Candidate Interviews: Ian Callaghan, Green Party
  46. Parliamentary Candidate Interviews: Lib Dem’s Adrian Ford
  47. Paliamentary Candidate Interview – Labour’s Darren Paffey
  48. Parliamentary Candidates Interviews: Lib Dem’s Eleanor Bell
  49. TV Debates: The Crucifixion of David Cameron
  50. Parliamentary Candidate Interview – Labour’s Rowenna Davis
  51. Parliamentary Candidate Interview, the Green Party’s Angela Mawle
  52. Can We Trust Politicians Who Act Like Schoolchildren?
  53. Parliamentary Candidate Interview – UKIP’s Sandra James
  54. Manifesto Focus: Labour
  55. Why Nuclear Weapons Are Imperative For The UK’s Security
  56. Southampton’s Role in the General Election Should Not Be Overshadowed by a Sausage Roll
  57. Just When You Thought UKIP Couldn’t Do Anything Right…
  58. What the Hell Do You Want?
  59. Which Political Leader Are You?
  60. The EU: To Be or Not To Be
  61. Your 2015 General Election Candidates
  62. What a Silly Sausage: Southampton UKIP Candidate Accused of Bribery
  63. UKIP Party Profile
  64. Conservative Party Profile
  65. The Leaders Debate: The Insurgents, The Pretender & The Incumbent
  66. SUPA’s Short and Sweet Guide to Voting on 7th May
  67. TV Debate: Clash of the Titans
  68. Leaders Debate Brings Hope For Progressive Politics
  69. TV Debates: David Cameron and Ed Miliband Versus Britain
  70. 14,000 Voters Missing From Electoral Role in Southampton – Register to Vote Now!
  71. Men’s Rights Party Set To Contest in General Elections
  72. A Royal Coup? – Queen Guitarist Brian May Considering Standing for Election
  73. Debating Over Debates
  74. Galloway Demands Inclusion in TV Debates
  75. The General Election 2015 – A Disunited Kingdom? 
  76. 99 Days To Go: The Most Unpredictable Election Yet!
  77. Poll Indicates Demand for Green Party to be Included in Election Debates
  78. Have You Registered To Vote?
  79. Is Sol Campbell running for Parliament?
  80. Salmond to Stand as MP
  81. Students May Hold the Key!
  82. The Green Party Should Not Be Included in the 2015 General Election Debates
  83. Parliamentary Candidate Interview: Alan Whitehead MP
  84. What’s at Stake for Students in the General Election?
  85. It’s Time For Politicians To Get Down With The Kids
  86. The Debates Debate
  87. Who Will Run The Country in 2015?
  88. New Year, New Government? New Politics?
  89. Newly Elected Itchen MP Accused of Helping UKIP Secure Labour Votes

Pause Editor 2015-7, History student on Erasmus, maker of low-quality satire. When not writing for Pause, I dabble in Travel and Politics.

Discussion1 Comment

Leave A Reply