The Premier League Transfer Window – Winners and Losers (Part 2)


As the transfer window finally draws to an end, we look at which clubs have won and lost as the new Premier League season is underway.

Crystal Palace

Best Signing: Eberechi Eze (from QPR, £16m) – a highly-rated attacking midfielder who has had some incred

Worst Signing: None – all signings have a place in Hodgson’s team.

Will Miss: Alexander Sorloth (to RB Leipzig, c. £20m) – 16 games, 0 goals for Palace. So why will they miss him? Well, after a superb loan spell where Sorloth scored 33 goals in 49 games for Trabzonspor, Palace may rue letting him go if the goals (and Wilfred Zaha) dry up.

Should’ve Got Rid of: Jordan Ayew – if anyone was to leave, I’d have got rid of him in place of Sorloth. Having said that, I do believe Palace have a good squad, such that no one should’ve left this summer.

Overall Review: A quiet window for Palace with real focus on going forward. A good attacking line with Michy Batshuayi leading and Zaha and Eze either side, and the Eagles can hope that this could be an even better campaign. Good defensive signings, with a chance for Jack Butland to revitalise his career ahead of EURO 2020. 9/10

In: Nathan Ferguson (from West Brom, tribunal), Eberechi Eze (from QPR, £16m), Nathaniel Clyne (from Liverpool, free); Jack Butland (from Stoke, undisclosed), Michy Batshuayi (from Chelsea, loan)

Out: Jaroslaw Jach (to Fortuna Sittard, loan), Dion-Curtis Henry (released), Jason Lokilo (to Doncaster Rovers, free), Alexander Sorloth (to RB Leipzig, undisclosed), Ryan Inniss (to Charlton Ath, free).


Best Signing: James Rodriguez (from Real Madrid, free) – what a coup for the Toffees. Still young enough to have several good years ahead of him (at age 29), and his opening games have shown he is, so far, worth his weight in gold.

Embed from Getty Images

Worst Signing: Niels Nkounkou (from Marseille, free) – again, it is one of those ‘worst of a good bunch’. Nkounkou made his debut against my club Fleetwood and I must admit he played very well – a youngster with a good future (just unlucky that Everton have had such a good window so he is the worst of the four incoming players!).

Will Miss: Leighton Baines (retired) – the Toffees legend retired after 13 years and he would’ve still been a good presence in the dressing room as a club captain. His consistency will be sorely missed.

Should’ve Got Rid of: Jordan Pickford – if they miss out on a successful season, it will unfortunately be the fault of England’s seemingly first choice goalkeeper. Error-strewn, they’ll be grateful for having signed a new goalkeeper.

Overall Review: Everton have had the perfect window, retaining their top talent and bringing in players of a high calibre – expect a good campaign from Ancelotti’s side. 10/10

In: Niels Nkounkou (from Marseille, free), Allan (from Napoli, £21.7m), James Rodriguez (from Real Madrid, free), Abdoulaye Doucoure (from Watford, £20m), Ben Godfrey (from Norwich, £20m), Robin Olsen (from Roma, loan).

Out: Luke Garbutt (to Blackpool, free), Fraser Hornby (to Reims, £1.8m), Cuco Martina (released), Oumar Niasse (released), Morgan Schneiderlin (to Nice, free), Leighton Baines (retired), Kieran Dowell (to Norwich, undisclosed), Maarten Stekelenburg (to Ajax, free), Sandro (to Huesca, free). 



Best Signing: Alphonse Areola (from PSG, loan) – personally, I see Areola as a top ‘keeper who only misses out on playing for PSG because of how incredible Keylor Navas is as a first choice. With a solid defence ahead of him, Areola could really do a good job for Fulham.

Worst Signing: Anthony Knockaert (from Brighton, £10.5m) – sent out on loan just a few months later. Never have I seen £10m spent so awfully.

Will Miss: Steven Sessegnon (to Bristol City, loan) – not quite at the same level as his twin brother, Sessegnon is still a key part of the Fulham squad who could’ve grown under Parker in the Premier League. Alas, he will be back at the end of the season – and will hope his loan pushes him into the first team.

Should’ve Got Rid of: Tim Ream – the centre-back used to be solid for the Cottagers but they have already been leaky and will hope their new reinforcements will help.

Overall Review: Fulham haven’t spent nearly as much as they did when they were promoted to the Premier League in the 2018-19 season, but they haven’t invested in the right positions this time around. Having said that, the reinforcements they have brought in do strengthen the squad in some places, particularly defensively after a late flurry of signings. 7/10

In: Anthony Knockaert (from Brighton, £10.5m), Antonee Robinson (from Wigan, £2m), Harrison Reed (from So’ton, undisclosed), Kenny Tete (from Lyon, undisclosed), Tosin Adarabioyo (from Man City, undisclosed), Terence Kongolo (from Huddersfield, undisclosed), Mario Lemina (from So’ton, loan), Alphonse Areola (from PSG, loan), Ola Aina (from Terino, loan), Ademola Lookman (from RB Leipzig, loan), Joachim Andersen (from Lyon, loan), Ruben Loftus-Cheek (from Chelsea, loan).

Out: Alfie Mawson (to Bristol City, loan), Steven Sessegnon (to Bristol City, loan), Marcus Bettinelli (to Middlesbrough, loan), Cyrus Christie (to Nott’m Forest, loan), Anthony Knockaert (to Nott’m Forest, loan), Luca de la Torre (to Heracles, free).

Leeds United

Best Signing: Diego Llorente (from Real Sociedad, undisclosed) – another solid and experienced defender to come in and support the Whites’ defensive line, something desperately needed after losing out on Ben White.

Worst Signing: Rodrigo (from Valencia, £26m) – not for a lack of talent, but for value for money. Rodrigo is a good striker but not for that sort of money – 35 goals in 5 years at Valencia doesn’t scream £26m to me.

Will Miss: Ben White (returned to Brighton). The loanee had an incredible season at Leeds and very much had the chance to be in the England squad. However, Bielsa will hope his defensive reinforcements – Koch and Llorente – can mask this huge loss.

Embed from Getty Images

Should’ve Got Rid of: Pablo Hernandez – he really lacks the ability to do well in the Premier League, at the age of 35. I don’t expect him to be a match winner, or even a starter, for Leeds.

Overall review: A good window for Leeds, but marred by the failure to sign Ben White. The goals conceded so far may mean that is a big, big loss for the Elland Road side. 8/10.

In: Helder Costa (from Wolves, undisclosed), Ilian Meslier (from Lorient, undisclosed), Joe Gelhardt (from Wigan, undisclosed), Rodrigo (from Valencia, £26m), Robin Koch (from Freiburg, undisclosed), Diego Llorente (from Real Sociedad, undisclosed), Raphinha (from Rennes, undisclosed), Jack Harrison (from Man City, loan). 

Out: Laurens de Bock (to Zulte Waregem, loan), Ryan Edmondson (to Aberdeen, loan), Jordan Stevens (to Swindon, loan), Mateusz Bogusz (to Logrones, loan), Robbie Gotts (to Lincoln, loan), Barry Douglas (to Blackburn, loan).

Leicester City

Best Signing: Timothy Castagne (from Atalanta, £21m) – someone who has impressed on the international stage for club and country, Castagne has a bright future ahead of him under Brendan Rodgers and will hope to solidify the back line again after the loss of Ben Chilwell (though he won’t be a like-for-like replacement).

Worst Signing: None, though they could’ve done with a top left-back to replace Chilwell.

Will Miss: Ben Chilwell (to Chelsea, £50m) – a great deal for someone who cost the Foxes nothing, but of course it means they lose one of their most talented young players who will be hard to replace.

Should’ve Got Rid of: Christian Fuchs – perhaps this is purely out of personal preference, but I’m not keen on Fuchs – he adds nothing but a salary to the Foxes, summed up by his performance against Arsenal in the Carabao Cup.

Overall review: Leicester needed to bring in more, I feel, to build on their Europa League spot in the last campaign. However, Castagne and Under will be good additions and they can expect to finish around the same spot this year. 5/10

In: Timothy Castagne (from Atalanta, £21m), Wes Fofana (from Saint-Ettiene, £30m), Cengiz Under (from Roma, loan).

Out: Rachid Gezzal (to Besiktas, loan), Filip Benkovic (to Cardiff, loan), Matty James (to Barnsley, loan), George Thomas (to QPR, free), Andy King (released), Bartosz Kapustka (to Legia Warsaw, undisclosed), Ben Chilwell (to Chelsea, c. £50m), Fousseni Diabate (to Trabzonspor, undisclosed), Adrien Silva (to Sampdoria, undisclosed). 

Look out for coming articles which continue our review of the window!


Sports Editor and 2nd Year Population & Geography student

Leave A Reply